I have some of my own personal experience and opinions in here on some of the products. Your mileage may vary. Hope I don't hurt anyone's feelings when I say I feel product A is crap, and product B is tits. I just want to cut out the bullshit items that slow you down, and only carry versatile pieces of gear that actually last.
Please add your two cents. This thread is basically a list that's gonna be "under construction" for a long time.
-=WHISTLES=-
The folks I've seen use whistles most efficiently thus far are Canyoneers. Canyoneers typically have to deal with a torrent of water crashing down around them, making verbal communication impractical. A couple blasts on a good whistle is easy to do, requires little energy, and is easy to understand.
For general mountaineering, one can use a whistle to communicate in the same manner, and also to communicate over long distances when or if a party becomes separated.
In bad (good, IMHO) weather, a whistle is a helluva lot easier to understand than yelling. Often times a climber says too much when they really just need to convey a point, such as "you're on belay!", or "I'm off rope/clipped into the anchor!".
My personal choice is the Fox 40 Micro Safety.
http://www.fox40world.com/index.cfm?DSP ... og&id=4130
This whistle is relatively flat, so it fits on my issue dog tags, and I can wear it under just about everything except body armor with hard plates (might be necessary in some canyons around here

Other Fox 40's are great on a lanyard on one's pack strap. I just don't like having stuff hanging off my pack strap doing winter climbing, etc.
*WHISTLE BLASTS*
1 short = off rope (canyoneering)
2 short = wait!
3 short/long (3 of anything) = I need help!
-=RADIOS=-
FRS/GMRS with extra batteries. Must be able to withstand whatever conditions you expect to encounter. I don't know much about radios or what's out there at the moment.
The Garmin Rino is a combo GPS - Radio. The plus side is obvious, but I don't know how long the battery lasts powering two devices, both basically working passively while one is climbing.
mattmaxon wrote:I use the uniden GMR2875-2CK my hands down favorite...when I use one![]()
-=HEADLAMPS=-
Headlamp brands:
-Black Diamond - http://www.blackdiamondequipment.com/en-us
-Petzl - http://www.petzl.com/en/outdoor/headlamps/all-headlamps
-Mammut - http://www.mammut.ch/
-Surefire - http://www.surefire.com/Headlamps
I currently use a Petzl Tikka. I used to think it was bright enough to work with, but it really isn't. Something that shoots a beam out to the end of a rope would be awesome.
Most outdoorsy folks are unfamiliar with Surefire. I doubt many people have bought the Saint headlamps because of the very high price. That said, my experience with Surefire is that their lights work perfectly, last for-freaking-ever, and are made with the best materials, by the best people out there. If I could only buy one flashlight or headlamp ever, it would be a Surefire product. That said, I'm broke as hell and I can't afford $185.


The only products of theirs I do not like are the inexpensive G2/Nitrolon series (the polymer models). They're less-than waterproof.
Their lights are very powerful. Some folks have melted their gear because they left the tailcap screwed down all the way, or thrown it in with a bunch of disorganized crap in their truck. These aren't the little cheesy flashlights you get at Wally World, so you hafta be careful with them.
The LED versions heat up less, and the batteries last longer. There's less of a chance of you burning your pack down with one of these if you're disorganized.

Hikin_Jim wrote:The Petzl Tikka is way too dim. They were an OK light in their day (like 8 years ago), but way outclassed these days. I've got a PrincetonTec EOS that I really like.
http://www.petzl.com/en/outdoor/myo-series/myo-xpmattmaxon wrote:Petzl Myo XP long lasting... High output when you need it.
-=KNIFE/MULTITOOL=-
Multitool brands:
-Leatherman - http://www.leatherman.com/
-Gerber - http://www.gerbergear.com/
-SOG - http://sogknives.com/
I have a Leatherman, am glad I don't have a Gerber, and wish I had a SOG. Your mileage may vary.
A multitool is generally more versatile than a knife. Since I carry both, I prefer a multitool without knife blades, since the damn things end up pulling out with every other tool and I just about cut my damn fingers off.
As for knives... being a "knife guy", I've seen both sides of the knife argument. There are folks who say you only need a Swiss Army knife with its crappy little non-locking blades, and there are some knife knuts who think you need a badass 7" CPM-S30V Crucible blade with carbon fibre scales and all that shit. The truth is somewhere in the middle, I guess. I have a ton of knives of all types, and I pretty much always have a small "Kiridashi" type knife, with a blade length of one inch. It's enough for most tasks, but obviously not going to be of any help if I need to make a lean-to or shelter, or dig a poop hole, or forage for and prepare food, etc.
IMHO the best buy on the market for a general purpose knife is the Cold Steel SRK.
http://www.coldsteel.com/srk.html
They can be found for pretty cheap ($120 MSRP is higher than I've sold them for). They don't have anything special about them, which is precisely what makes them good. The handle is very grippy, and the blade is VERY sharp out of the box. I believe their blade length to be ideal for most outdoor tasks.
It can be a real pain in the ass to find a decent knife. There are tons of super awesome tactical knives that you can shoot down helicopters with but you can't spread butter on a friggin' piece of bread with, and then there are a few good ones that'll do most anything hidden in the mess.
A knife should be kept as sharp as possible. "It doesn't need to be razor sharp!" is often uttered before someone accidentally jabs theirself with their crappy dull knife. Sharper = less work = safer, straight up. A dull knife is an improperly-maintained tool. Shaving sharpness can be a pain in the ass to achieve (or I just suck at sharpening), but you want to make sure it's sharp enough to cut cord and webbing effortlessly WITHOUT serrations.
I personally do not like serrations. One can sharpen their knife in the field more easily if it lacks serrations (using a stone, curb, etc). Most folks just use serrations after they've realized their knife is dull and they're too lazy to get it sharpened.
http://www.sierratradingpost.com/p/316, ... -Pack.htmlHikin_Jim wrote:In terms of a fixed blade knife, I've got a Kershaw Antelope that I really like. Inexpensive, fairly light (about 1/4 lbs), nicely balanced, good quality.
-=WATER FILTERS=-
Hikin_Jim wrote:With respect to a water filter, that seems like an odd choice. Most of the water away from roads in the San Gabs is pretty clean. I regularly drink w/o any treatment and have done so since the 60's, and I've never had a problem. Even if I had to drink water in a heavily used area (where I wouldn't normally drink), Giardia takes a week or three to show up, so I'd have plenty of time to get out of a jam. A filter seems like a lot to lug around for not much pay off. If I were really worried about bugs in the water, I might bring some chlorine dioxide tabs with me.
Zé wrote:FWIW, I've drank out of the east fork ~ Iron Fork and Dry Gulch and had no issues. I would consider both areas low on human use / flow ratio.
mattmaxon wrote:The gold standard is Katadyn.
I have a Katadyn Pocket which has a 20 year warranty, built like a tank and weighs like one too. This has been relegated to my auto earth quake kit
http://www.katadyn.com/katadyn-products ... yn-pocket/
I also have a Katadyn Camp which I use occasionally kinda a pain to set up but it beats pumping gallons of water.
http://www.katadyn.com/en/katadyn-produ ... adyn-camp/
I've used a Katadyn Expedition many times on backcountry work projects.
http://www.katadyn.com/en/katadyn-produ ... xpedition/
The one I use currently is a MSR Sweetwater I feel it is a good compromise between weight and cost. Certainly not the best but it works.
http://www.cascadedesigns.com/msr/water ... er/product
-=OTHER=-
Hikin_Jim wrote:Of the ten essentials, I personally can't recommend a map & compass strongly enough. Doing your homework in advance and staying on top of your map while en route will prevent trouble before it starts.
Beyond the ten essentials, I typically carry:
- Duct tape
- Important Meds (3 day supply) -- Prescriptions, Antihistamines (e.g. Benadryl), Imodium, Anti-Inflammatory, etc.
- Whistle -- Micro Fox 40
- Signal Mirror
- Shelter (e.g. space blanket, space blanket bivvy sack, tube tent, etc.)
- Rain gear (poncho for three season, Gore Tex top & bottom for winter) -- may be left behind in So. Cal in summer
- Watch
- Bandana
- Insect repellent (DEET or Picaridin)
- Cell phone
Please add whatever you feel is necessary!