Trip planning, history, announcements, books, movies, opinions, etc.
25 posts
• Page 1 of 1
kristo5747
Posts: 102
Joined: Tue Sep 15, 2009 3:09 pm
Postby kristo5747 »
Disclaimer: this is gonna sound weird but I'd hate to be a moron about this. I need your opinion.
/================/
When I am out hiking and eat a banana/orange/apple, I take the detritus (i.e. peel or core) and put it in a ziploc bag. Once I am home, the ziploc bag goes in the trash.
But what about...well, um, when you have to, you know, go number two? I always bury my waste but am I supposed to bury the used TP or ziploc it too??
lol. This is actually a debate that some people take very seriously.
Personally, I always just bury the TP with my #2 about 6" down. I'm pretty good about digging a decent sized hole.
The purists say that your TP won't degrade, and that you should pack out or burn your TP. Some hard core LNT types will pack a lighter in their poop kit so they can burn their TP. I'm not convinced that TP won't degrade, but above tree line they may have a point.
Some ultra light, ultra LNT'ers advocate that you shouldn't use TP at all...
(and seriously I'm not joking, just visit backpackinglight.com some time)
Here's some really good articles (and discussions on other boards) about the subject - this should make it easier for you to choose based on where you are in the wilderness, different conditions should dictate your choice as HJ suggested, some areas do not get enough "water/moister" to facilitate the decomp process - it's a very "crappy subject" ( ) but one we all need to think about when nature calls
The obvious answer is not to go while in the woods. Wait 'till you get home -- or at least to McPlumbing.
Then, after you flush, you won't even have to think about it!
It's a little tougher in the chaparral covered mountains of S Cal than in the Rockies where I believe most of the BPL staff spend their time.
The one question I've always had though: Isn't it, um, un- environmental to rip up grass or tear the leaves off a bush? If these practices were widely adopted, wouldn't that cause environmental damage, particularly above tree line or in arid areas?
HJ, you may be able to dig a deep enough hole but it seems that some of our hiking colleagues can not.
It is frustrating to come across used TP in the woods. My vote is to pack it out. It is very easy to do... just take a spare baggie with you when you do the deed.
I always enter the mountains prepared, and that includes a small roll of toilet paper. But the greener members of our population don't think about it. That's why the old-timers refer to toilet paper as "mountain money". When someone is in need, you can trade it for just about anything.
I was never concerned about the biodegradability of TP, but if it makes you feel better you can use a marine grade toilet paper like they use on boats. It's not as comfy as supermarket TP, but it decomposes quickly.
If you do not want to pack out the used paper, NEVER BURN IT! There was a fire that started at the confluence of the East and West Forks of the San Gabriel River (was it the Bridge Fire?) that was caused by burning toilet paper. Someone recreating with a church group tried to do the right thing and lit the TP on fire, then a wind picked up and took it into the grass and chaparral.
Of course, you should do us all a favor and dig your hole well away from the trail. Just make sure that cougarmagic doesn't get you on video
EManBevHills wrote:The obvious answer is not to go while in the woods. Wait 'till you get home -- or at least to McPlumbing.
Then, after you flush, you won't even have to think about it!
I have friends that start dosing imodium a couple days before a trip--seals 'em up tighter than a drum. Except for the gas. The normal high altitude flatulence seems to worsen with this strategy.
When I was a boy back in Scotland, my Da used to put the previous year's Sears catalog in the outhouse. We could always tell when spring was coming because we'd be getting into the bridal section.
There is an excellent book on this topic, appropriately titled: "How To Shit In The Woods" by Kathleen Meyer. I will still practice the burning method, which is mentioned in the book, if I am in a relatively safe environment and then make sure there are no embers with my "fire hose." (Hey, I'm not the first one to call it that)
If you ever hike the main Mount Whitney trail you will not only have to pack out your used TP but your excrement as well! Once you've experienced the joy of using and then carrying a full WAG bag to the top of the highest peak in the lower 48 you will definately make a point to eat plenty of cheese the night before!
Mike P wrote:HJ, you may be able to dig a deep enough hole but it seems that some of our hiking colleagues can not... My vote is to pack it out.
Well, Mike, I doubt the people too lazy to bury their TP are going to pack it out. The only people who would pack it out would be the ones who weren't causing a problem in the first place.
The real solution is to avoid TP! The trick to avoiding TP is of course identifying the correct species for your wiping needs.
Is it possible to leave nothing behind? Even if you annihilate all of the matter in your wake, there would still be empty space, which is certainly something.
if one's definition of "nature" is all that isn't man-made, then our mere presence in nature would tarnish it...we'll always leave something but its a matter of what level we feel comfortable in accepting.
i draw the line at allowing Taco into nature with his weird shoes
My father was a very religious man. Wiping one's ass with the Playmate of the Month would have been considered sacrilege.
We were fortunate that Sears turned out to be a successful company. As our family grew, so did the size of the catalog.
